A quiet coastal living room with a large window overlooking established hillside homes and the Pacific Ocean.

Will the New Condos at Price and Dolliver Change the Market on Pismo Heights?

At the triangle where Dolliver Street meets Price Street, at the north entrance to downtown Pismo Beach, the block planned for redevelopment holds a deserted gas station, about ten homes and a century-old building that once housed the Shell Cafe and more recently Oasis Moroccan Restaurant. The San Luis Obispo Tribune reported that all of it is slated to come down for the Gateway project, a three-story mixed-use development by Coastal Community Builders with a public plaza, four commercial condominium spaces and 39 residential condominiums.

For anyone comparing homes on the hillside above that corner, Gateway is the most visible new housing in the area. Its effect on the Pismo Heights house market will be small. The city describes the hill as nearly built out, and the new homes at its base are a different kind of property, sold to buyers who make a different trade.

The hill is close to built out

The City of Pismo Beach's updated General Plan and Local Coastal Program came before the California Coastal Commission at its October 2026 hearing. It describes the Pismo Heights planning area as low-density residential, with some medium-density homes in the southern portion and high-density residential along Highway 101. The plan says the area "is almost completely built out and provides many with dramatic views." The passage is in the Coastal Commission's published exhibits.

On a hill that is almost completely built out, a buyer is choosing among houses that already stand, so nearly every listing is a resale and the supply moves with owners' decisions to sell. When a well-kept house with an open view comes up near Longview, the buyers bidding on it have few comparable choices in the same pocket, and that will stay true however many units go up at the bottom of the hill.

What is going up at the bottom of the hill

Gateway's residential mix, as the Tribune reported from the city staff report, is 33 two-bedroom condominiums between 1,085 and 1,851 square feet, five studios at 460 square feet and one one-bedroom at 808 square feet. The residential building fills the 1.2-acre block across Bay Street from the plaza. The building is three stories, and because the site slopes, parts of it rise to 45 feet. The city described Bay Street as a view corridor through the project.

The Planning Commission approved the project on June 10, 2025. On September 2, 2025, the City Council voted unanimously to deny two appeals and approve the final design. The revisions added 21 off-site parking spaces and a voluntary $27,000 contribution toward public parking. The Council also kept Bay Street two-way and required a median with a break in it so drivers heading north on Price Street can still turn left onto Bay. KSBY's coverage of the Council vote reported that parking was the main concern raised by members of the public at the hearing.

Coastal Community Builders markets the project as Ocean Terraces, calls it "Pismo's newest and most exclusive ocean-view community," and is taking an interest list ahead of the official sales launch.

Compare that unit mix with the hill. Most of the Gateway homes are two-bedroom condominiums in a mixed-use building with commercial space at street level, right where downtown begins. The plan describes Pismo Heights as mostly low-density residential with views. A two-bedroom a short walk from the pier, with no yard to keep up, suits one buyer; a detached house with outdoor space and a view up the hill suits another. The two groups of buyers will meet at a few open houses, and they will mostly bid on different homes.

What the builder's pricing shows about condos

The builder's own pages show how new condos in South County are being sold this fall. The Ocean Terraces page carries the banner "ASK ABOUT OUR 5.99% fixed rate," together with fall incentives described as "special pricing, premium appliances, and custom design upgrades." The California Association of Realtors puts the average 30-year fixed rate in California at 6.86% in September 2026, up from 6.35% a year earlier. A builder that advertises a rate below the market average is using the loan to compete for buyers, on top of the price.

Grover Beach shows how far that goes. At Encore, the builder's condominium project on West Grand Avenue, the page recently listed a 695-square-foot unit at $450,000 and a 1,003-square-foot view unit at $725,000. One of the two-bedroom ocean-view listings showed a $20,000 builder incentive. At Trinity, the builder's Grover Beach community, the page recently listed homes from $899,000 to $1,150,000 at 1,783 to 1,953 square feet, with "Builder Incentives/Flex Credit available."

A buyer considering a new condo this fall can negotiate the rate, credits and upgrades as well as the price. A buyer considering a resale house on Pismo Heights is negotiating with one owner over one house. Concessions on a new two-bedroom condo, whether a rate buydown or a $20,000 incentive, do not show what a three-bedroom house on the hill will sell for, because the two properties are not interchangeable. Rate offers, credits and loan terms depend on each buyer's situation, so read this as general market information, not financial or legal advice, and confirm any loan terms with your own lender.

The county pace, and where the hill fits

Countywide, the market has slowed a little without turning. According to the California Association of Realtors' September 2026 report, the median price of an existing single-family home in San Luis Obispo County was $950,000 in September 2026, compared with $912,500 in September 2025. Median time on market in the county was 39 days in September 2026, up from 32 days a year earlier, and the unsold inventory index was 3.5 months.

These are county figures for detached houses, so they say nothing directly about one hillside street. They do set the background for the Gateway sales launch. When homes take longer to sell across the county, builders add incentives to move units, and the Ocean Terraces page shows that pattern. Pismo Heights, by the city's own description, is almost completely built out, so slower county sales give hill buyers more time to decide and more room to negotiate on terms and repairs without adding to the number of competing houses on the hill.

Our earlier look at why Pismo Beach's median price splits into several submarkets applies here as well. Once Gateway units close, a citywide Pismo Beach number will mix new downtown condos with hillside houses. That figure will describe the two products together and will not describe either one well.

The timeline residents will feel

In December 2025, the City Council considered temporarily closing Bay Street between Price and Dolliver during construction. The builder then projected a start in late February or early March 2026 and a reopening by July 1, 2027. City Council minutes record the adoption of Resolution R-2026-084 on the closure. Permit listings show a commercial demolition permit for 1481 Price Street dated June 29, 2026.

If you drive down from the hill, expect construction at the Price and Dolliver corner to overlap with the Highway 101 widening work along Price Street. Buyers who tour the hill on a weekday will see both projects. Neither one changes how many houses are on the hill.

Quick answers

Will the Gateway condos make Pismo Heights houses easier to buy?

Probably not much. The city's plan describes the hill as almost completely built out. Most Gateway units are two-bedroom condos, a product that competes with other condos more than with hillside houses.

Should a Pismo Heights seller worry about competing with new construction?

The builder's incentives are aimed at condo buyers. A house on the hill competes with the few other houses listed nearby at the same time, so what other houses on the hill are selling for is the better guide to pricing.

When will the condos be finished?

Approval came in 2025, and the builder's December 2025 projection put Bay Street's reopening at July 1, 2027. The builder is collecting an interest list ahead of the sales launch.

If you are weighing a house on Pismo Heights against a new condo near the pier, or wondering whether Gateway changes what your own house on the hill is worth, Freedom One Realty can compare recent sales on your street with the new-construction pricing at the bottom of the hill. You can start with a home valuation or schedule a free consultation with Julie to go over the comparison.

Partner With Julie

If you are considering selling or repositioning your property, Julie welcomes a confidential consultation to discuss a customized market strategy tailored to your goals.

Follow Me on Instagram